The Astral Library by Kate Quinn * *
I read The Astral Library by Kate Quinn for the 2026 PopSugar Reading Challenge, prompt number 31, “A book that makes you feel FOMO.” Sadly, this was a real disappointment for me. The premise sounded exactly like something I would love. There is a magical library where people can enter books, live inside stories, and move through literature as if the pages were real places. The library is also in danger somehow, which made me expect a fun, imaginative adventure through books, with mystery, magic, and a real sense of wonder. The idea is wonderful. The execution, for me, was not. The first problem was that the book felt very much like it was aimed at BookTok. I know the author has said that she chose books she personally loved, and that the public domain books included were ones she saw as great classics. But while reading, it felt like a roll call of the usual big titles and familiar references. Fourth Wing gets mentioned. George R. R. Martin gets mentioned. Oz, Narnia, and Tolkien co...