Unapologetic Reviews

I read The Witch by Freida McFadden for two reasons. First, it was part of my October Read-Witch-a-Thon, and second, it was my October 2026 Pick of the Month. This was also my very first Freida McFadden book, which is rather surprising considering how enormously popular she is. I've heard plenty of opinions about her writing, both good and bad, but I'd never actually tried any of her books myself. I wasn't entirely sure what to expect, so I went into this one with an open mind, curious to see whether her writing would work for me. And I must say, I was impressed! I gave this book five stars, and I thoroughly enjoyed the experience. The Witch is a mystery thriller told across two timelines, one set in the present day and the other in seventeenth-century Massachusetts. Both stories revolve around Pemberton Manor, an old house with a rather disturbing history, and the women whose lives become entangled with it. In the present-day timeline, we follow Julia Barlow, a young...

I read A Time of Witches by Madeline Martin as part of my Read-Witch-a-Thon 2026, and this turned out to be one of the better books I've read for the challenge. I really enjoyed the combination of historical fiction, witchcraft, mystery, and time travel, especially because the story follows two women living centuries apart whose fates are closely connected. The novel has two timelines. In the present day, we follow Lilith Legare, a young woman living in Savannah, Georgia, whose mother has recently died. While going through her mother's belongings, Lilith discovers research into their family history, which leads her to an old manor house in England called Brackenmere. She has also been experiencing strange dreams and visions, including a warning that she is going to disappear. Somehow, her family's past seems to be connected to whatever is happening to her, so she decides to travel to England to investigate. When Lilith arrives at Brackenmere, she discovers that the man...

I read Henry Tudor Must Die by Jillian Laine as part of the Read Witch-a-Thon 2026, which is my own witchy October reading challenge, and I gave it three stars. On paper, this should have been a five-star book for me. I love witches and magic, I love historical fiction, and the Tudor period is one of my favourite historical eras and one I know quite a lot about. Add Anne Boleyn and Catherine of Aragon teaming up to take revenge on Henry VIII, and really, what more could I ask for? Unfortunately, while I loved the premise, I never became emotionally invested in the people carrying it. The story begins shortly before Anne Boleyn's execution. Anne is a witch, and magic gives her a way to escape her fate, although it comes at a considerable physical cost. Catherine of Aragon has also faked her death, and the two former rivals find themselves working together. Both have lost almost everything because of Henry, and both are particularly concerned about their daughters, Mary and Eliz...

I received an ARC of The Fallen Faithful by R.A. Sandpiper in exchange for an honest review. I really loved this book, although that probably will not come as a huge surprise because I have read everything R.A. Sandpiper has published. She is actually one of my favourite authors, and rather wonderfully, I originally discovered her through TikTok. One of the things I have consistently loved about her books is her world building. She has an incredible imagination for creating worlds that feel distinctive and complex, and The Fallen Faithful absolutely did not disappoint. This time, we are in an Ancient Greek inspired world built around a pantheon of very real gods. I particularly loved the religion because the gods themselves are based around fairly familiar concepts. There are gods associated with things like love, death and pain, rather than every god having an incredibly elaborate and unusual domain. That actually made the pantheon feel more believable to me. Historically, polyt...

I read János vitéz by Sándor Petőfi as part of my project to read the mandatory and suggested literature taught in Hungarian schools from grades five to twelve. This was actually a reread for me because János vitéz is one of those books almost every Hungarian encounters at school. I first read it when I was about ten, so coming back to it as an adult was a very different experience. János vitéz , which can be translated as John the Valiant , is a narrative epic poem written by Petőfi in 1844, when he was only twenty one years old. Considering that Petőfi died at only twenty six, basically everything he ever wrote was written when he was ridiculously young, and this poem is a particularly good example of just how much he had already developed his distinctive voice. The story begins with a young shepherd called Kukorica Jancsi. His name is a little difficult to translate, although the traditional English translation calls him Johnny Corncob because he was found abandoned in a cornf...

I read The Witches of Cambridge by Alice Hoffman as part of the 2026 PopSugar Reading Challenge, for prompt number 33, "a book about college". I also made it the first book of my October 2026 Read Witch-a-Thon, so I was killing two birds with one stone. Unfortunately, this was not the strongest start to my witchy reading month. I think this is another case where the blurb gave me a very different idea of the book I was going to read. Based on the description, I imagined two young witches arriving at Radcliffe College in 1950s Cambridge, joining Lilith House, essentially a sorority house for witches, and then realizing that girls from the society were disappearing. Naturally, I assumed Ava and Lauren would team up to figure out what was happening. This was my first Alice Hoffman novel, although of course I knew her as the author of Practical Magic , and it is immediately obvious why she has had such a long career. Her prose is gorgeous. The descriptions of Cambridge, the c...

After reading Sleeping Murder by Agatha Christie, I watched two television adaptations of the novel. The first was the BBC Miss Marple adaptation starring Joan Hickson, originally broadcast in two parts in January 1987. The second was the 2006 adaptation from ITV’s Agatha Christie’s Marple , starring Geraldine McEwan. I enjoyed both of them, but they take almost completely opposite approaches to adapting the book. And from this point onwards, there are going to be spoilers for the book and both adaptations. The 1987 BBC version is by far the more faithful of the two. There are changes, but most of them are relatively minor and feel like the sort of changes you expect when adapting a novel for television. For example, Gwenda and Giles are already together when they are looking for their house, whereas in the novel Gwenda arrives in England ahead of Giles and finds the house by herself. The adaptation also condenses the gradual process through which Gwenda realizes that she somehow...

I read Sleeping Murder by Agatha Christie for the Read Christie 2026 Reading Challenge. This year’s overall theme is “Biggest, Best and Beloved,” and the October prompt was “Best Cold Case,” which is an extremely appropriate category for this book because the murder at the centre of the story has been sleeping for almost twenty years. There is also something a little sad about reading Sleeping Murder because it was the final Miss Marple novel to be published. It came out posthumously in 1976, although Christie had actually written it decades earlier, during the Second World War, and deliberately kept it back for later publication. So it is not really an elderly Christie saying goodbye to Miss Marple. Still, knowing that this was the last Miss Marple novel readers received gives it a strange sense of finality, particularly when the book itself contains some lovely references to her earlier cases. The story begins with Gwenda Reed, a young woman who has recently arrived in England fr...

I read Jackaby by William Ritter as part of the 2026 PopSugar Reading Challenge. This was for prompt number 19, "a book about teen angst", and I think seventeen year old Abigail Rook running away from home, joining a dinosaur dig in Eastern Europe, and then deciding on impulse to sail to America rather than return to her parents definitely qualifies. The book takes place in 1892, which I found particularly funny because I recently read The Yellow Wallpaper, which was published in 1892. What are the chances? Apparently I am accidentally spending quite a lot of time in 1892 at the moment. Our POV character is Abigail Rook, a seventeen year old English girl who has recently arrived in New Fiddleham, New England. She comes from a fairly intellectual family, but she is frustrated by the limitations placed on her because she is a girl. She wants adventure. When she is prevented from joining her father on his travels, she eventually takes matters into her own hands and joins a pale...

One woman's utopia is another man's dystopia. I read Herland by Charlotte Perkins Gilman after hearing about it while I was reading The Yellow Wallpaper , and I was immediately intrigued by the idea of a feminist utopia written in 1915. I'm actually much more familiar with dystopias than utopias. Dystopia is one of my favourite genres, even though I don't read it that often anymore, and I've read most of the classics. So I was curious. What would a feminist writing more than a hundred years ago consider an ideal society for women? At first, Herland sounds pretty great. The story follows three American men who are exploring a remote part of South America when they hear rumours about a mysterious country inhabited entirely by women. They eventually manage to enter this isolated land and discover an advanced civilisation that has existed without men for about two thousand years. And, obviously, the first question is: if there are no men, where are all these women c...