The Housewife by Natalie Barelli * * * *
Most of the books in this project dealt directly with tradwife influencers. Yesteryear, Trad Wife: A Novel, The Trad Wife, and Everyone Is Lying to You all explored women constructing some version of traditional femininity for an online audience. Their homes, marriages, pregnancies, recipes, and carefully chosen dresses became part of a public performance. The Stepford Wives obviously predates social media, but it examines the darker fantasy beneath the same ideal.
The Housewife is different. There are no influencers, no social media empire, and no ideological community built around traditional gender roles. Its protagonist simply enjoys being a housewife. Jodie loves cooking, cleaning, and maintaining an immaculate home. Cleaning genuinely calms her. She is meticulous about everything, from the arrangement of the house to the meals she prepares. Domestic labour is not something being forced upon her, nor is it something she performs for an audience. It is the life she actively wants.
The question is whether wanting to cook and clean is enough to make someone a tradwife.
That connection felt slightly tenuous after I finished the book. Jodie does not work outside the home, and she takes considerable pride in being a wife who keeps an immaculate house and prepares elaborate meals. However, there are no children, no religious ideology, and very little interest in submission or conventional morality. Jodie may look like the perfect traditional wife from the outside, but she enters her marriage with an agenda that has nothing to do with devotion.
She believes her husband murdered her sister.
Jodie marries Dr Roy Davies, a wealthy and respected psychologist living in Beverly Hills. Roy’s previous wife, Deborah, died under suspicious circumstances. What Roy does not know is that Deborah was Jodie’s older sister. He also does not know that Jodie has changed her name or that she has recently been released from prison after serving time for manslaughter.
Jodie’s original plan is relatively modest. She wants to gain access to Roy’s home, perhaps by getting hired as a housekeeper or cook, and investigate Deborah’s final months. Instead, her first meeting with Roy goes far better than she expected. Their relationship develops rapidly, Jodie claims to be pregnant, and Roy actually marries her.
She finds herself living inside the house where her sister spent the final part of her life.
The house is beautiful, expensive, and perfectly maintained, but Deborah’s presence still hangs over it. Roy’s friends remember her. The housekeeper knew her. Her possessions and routines have left impressions behind. Jodie begins examining everyone around Roy, including Deborah’s friends, Roy’s former associates, and the housekeeper who seems to know far more about the household than she is willing to say.
That investigation was the strongest part of the book for me. Jodie is not a professional detective, and she certainly does not behave like one. She makes several significant mistakes, sometimes because she acts too quickly and sometimes fumbles things. There were moments when I thought she was being remarkably foolish, especially considering how much she had risked simply by entering Roy’s life.
At the same time, those mistakes made sense for the character. Jodie is not trained to investigate a murder. She is driven by grief, anger, and her absolute conviction that Roy killed Deborah. She has built her entire new identity around getting close enough to prove it. Once she is inside the house, she cannot simply step back and consider the evidence calmly. She needs Roy to be guilty because that belief has given direction to her life.
Jodie herself was much harder for me to like.
There is something sinister about her almost from the beginning. Her love of domesticity does not make her gentle or nurturing. Her spotless kitchen, carefully prepared food, and perfectly ordered rooms sit beside her lies, manipulation, and capacity for violence. She can be helpful, and she does eventually assist people who need her, but that does not turn her into a conventionally good person.
She is not the innocent second wife wandering into a dangerous marriage. She enters Roy’s home deliberately, concealing her identity and her criminal history. She manipulates him into marriage by claiming to be pregnant. She searches through private belongings, lies to almost everyone she meets, and is prepared to destroy lives in order to uncover the truth.
That made her interesting even when I did not particularly like her.
Her housewife identity also becomes part of the deception. Roy and the people around him see a young woman who enjoys cooking, cleaning, and caring for her husband. They assume that makes her simple. They see the polished surfaces without recognising how much calculation lies underneath them. Jodie knows precisely what people expect a devoted housewife to look like, and she uses those expectations to move through Roy’s world.
In that sense, the novel does fit into my project more than I initially thought. Jodie is not selling domestic perfection online, but she is still performing it. Her immaculate home creates a reassuring picture. It makes her seem harmless. It allows people to underestimate her.
The mystery itself kept me engaged. I identified the killer quite early, but then the story introduced enough doubt to make me abandon my original theory. I became convinced that I had been wrong, only for my first suspicion to turn out to be correct after all. I enjoyed that because the book did not hide the answer behind a completely random final revelation. The clues were present. The story simply redirected my attention at the right moment.
The final resolution was also more interesting than a straightforward exposure and arrest would have been.
Without revealing exactly what happens, the ending is morally ambiguous. Evil is not entirely removed from the world, and justice does not arrive through a clean legal process. Several characters have committed terrible acts, but the consequences do not fall evenly. Someone dangerous remains free. At the same time, it is possible to argue that everyone receives some version of what they deserve.
I was not angry with the ending. Its moral uncertainty suited the rest of the novel because this was never a story populated by innocent people making reasonable decisions. Almost everyone is hiding something. Love is tangled with possession. Care becomes surveillance. Domestic service becomes a way of gaining control over another person’s body and environment.
The Housewife was certainly a departure from the other books in my Trad Wife Reading Project. Jodie is not an influencer, she does not promote traditional values, and she is not trying to persuade other women to follow her lifestyle. She simply prefers domestic work and has constructed her ideal life around being a wife in a beautiful home.
Admittedly, the beautiful home also happens to belong to the man she suspects of murdering her sister.
I am still not entirely convinced that this was the perfect choice for the project, but I am not sorry I included it. The writing was engaging, the investigation held my attention, and the morally grey conclusion gave me more to think about than a conventional thriller ending would have done.
I would recommend this to readers who enjoy fast psychological thrillers, deeply unreliable protagonists, unpleasant characters, and mysteries in which justice is considerably messier than the law.
Jodie may not be a tradwife in the modern ideological sense, but she understands the power of looking like the perfect wife. In this house, domestic perfection is not a promise of safety. It is camouflage.
Comments
Post a Comment