Witch Season by Julia Bianco (Broken Coven #1) * * * *
Witch Season by Julia Bianco was my eighth book for the 2026 Read Witch-a-Thon, and I gave it four stars. This is an urban fantasy with a contemporary setting, a secret magical society, a bit of mystery, and a rather predictable romance. While I enjoyed the book, particularly its interesting magic system and the social issues it explores, I felt that the various conflicts were resolved a little too easily.
The story takes place in our world, except that witches exist alongside ordinary people, operating within their own society. There are two main groups of witches. Some are born into established magical families and grow up learning how to control their abilities, while others develop magic unexpectedly, usually during their teenage years. These witches, who come from nonmagical families, have no idea what is happening to them until their powers suddenly manifest in an event known as a snap, often with disastrous consequences. Because they have never been taught how to control their magic, this initial outburst can cause considerable destruction and even result in people dying.
What makes this particularly interesting is that magic is a finite resource. Every witch has a magical core, and once that core has been depleted, their magic is gone forever. Witches who experience these uncontrolled snaps are at a significant disadvantage because they often burn through a considerable portion of their reserves before they even understand what is happening. Consequently, they may have much less magic left to use throughout their lives. There are ways to replenish or increase magical reserves, but these methods tend to be illegal, dangerous, or morally questionable.
Another interesting aspect of the magic system is the distinction between settled and unsettled magic. Settled magic is magic that a witch has learned to control, while unsettled magic is unpredictable and potentially dangerous. Witches can control magic through sheer force of will, but the results do not always correspond to their intentions. Even when they know what they want to accomplish, the magic may manifest in unexpected ways, sometimes with serious consequences.
One way to make spellcasting more reliable is through the use of magical runes stored in special books. Witches can draw these runes from the books and use them to perform specific spells, giving them much greater control over the results. Some runes can be used multiple times, while others disappear after a single use and must be obtained again. However, these books are not simply written or manufactured. Creating them requires a young witch to surrender their entire magical reserve, permanently giving up their abilities to fill a book with runes.
This creates a rather disturbing system of magical exploitation, especially because one powerful coven called Noctus, based in New York, controls the production and distribution of these books. They also develop new runes, effectively giving them authority over the rest of the magical community in the United States. We don't learn much about magical societies elsewhere in the world, because apparently, as usual, nothing exists outside the United States.
The story primarily follows Katherine, a young witch who was not born into a magical family. When her powers first manifested during her snap, the resulting catastrophe caused several deaths, leaving her frightened and isolated. She was eventually taken in by Sylvia, the leader of a smaller coven called Aestas, who helped her learn to control her abilities. Katherine has remained fiercely loyal to Sylvia ever since, viewing her as both a mentor and a parental figure.
Aestas operates under the authority of Noctus, although it maintains a certain degree of independence. Sylvia herself was once associated with the powerful coven and was even close to its leaders, but their relationship ended badly. The exact circumstances surrounding her departure remain somewhat unclear, even after the story reveals more about her past. We learn that she had an abusive childhood and has always struggled with authority, but I never felt that the book adequately explained what actually caused the final rupture.
Things become complicated when the son of Noctus's leaders, Silas, arrives to inspect Aestas, including its magical books and protective wards. His presence immediately raises suspicions because it seems that Noctus may be looking for an excuse to interfere with Aestas or even take control of it. When a mysterious incident occurs, Katherine and Silas find themselves investigating what happened, despite their initial distrust of one another.
There are also mysterious magical substances circulating within the community, including a dangerous potion being sold to ordinary humans, creating several interconnected plotlines.
One of the aspects I appreciated most was the book's exploration of privilege and discrimination within magical society. Witches born into established families have access to education, resources, protection, and a community that understands their abilities. They are taught how to use magic safely from childhood and can preserve their magical reserves because they know what they are doing. Those born into ordinary families receive none of these advantages.
When their magic manifests during a snap, often violently, these teenagers are suddenly considered dangerous. They may have accidentally injured someone, destroyed property, or even killed people without understanding what they were doing. Many feel compelled to leave their families because they are terrified of causing further harm. Yet instead of offering them guidance, most covens refuse to accept them because their unsettled magic is considered a threat.
Essentially, these children are told to disappear, preferably somewhere remote where they cannot hurt anyone, and somehow figure out how to control their abilities on their own. They are teenagers who have lost their homes, have little or no money, and possess dangerous powers they do not understand. What exactly are they supposed to do?
The hypocrisy becomes even more apparent when we learn that many of these same witches eventually provide the magical reserves used to create rune books. Having experienced nothing but suffering and rejection because of their abilities, they often choose to surrender their magic permanently. Once they have learned enough control to transfer their powers into a book, they can return to ordinary society and leave the magical world behind. The established covens benefit from their sacrifice while refusing to provide them with the support they desperately need.
Sylvia and Katherine are trying to change this through a training programme for young witches from nonmagical families. Instead of abandoning them, they offer a safe environment where these teenagers can learn to settle and control their magic and eventually become members of Aestas. Katherine herself was the first person to benefit from this approach, and she understands better than anyone how much difference it can make.
I really liked this aspect of the story because it highlights how much of the supposed danger associated with unsettled witches is created by the magical establishment itself. These children are not inherently more irresponsible or malicious than those born into magical families. They simply haven't had the same opportunities to learn. Rather than acknowledging this, the powerful covens treat them as a problem to be removed, even opposing programmes designed to help them.
The book makes a clear point about inherited privilege and the way institutions can perpetuate inequality while claiming to protect society. Those who already possess power and resources have little incentive to share them, especially when the existing system benefits them. The magical establishment has convinced itself that excluding these young witches is necessary for everyone's safety, without seriously considering that providing them with proper education might solve the problem.
Unfortunately, while I found the worldbuilding and its underlying social commentary compelling, I wasn't quite as impressed by the actual mysteries.
There are several different conflicts running throughout the novel, but most of them are resolved surprisingly quickly and conveniently. The characters encounter a problem, investigate it for a while, and then somehow stumble upon the solution. I rarely felt that they had to work particularly hard to figure things out, and I would have preferred to see Katherine and the other characters demonstrate more ingenuity.
The book also includes chapters from the main villain's perspective, which is an interesting narrative choice but one that didn't entirely work for me. On the one hand, these chapters allow us to understand the villain's motivations and see how they justify their actions. On the other hand, they remove much of the mystery because we already know who is responsible for what is happening.
I can appreciate the intention behind this approach. Rather than focusing on the identity of the villain, the story becomes more concerned with their motivations and how the protagonists will eventually uncover the truth. However, I personally would have preferred to discover the answers alongside Katherine. Instead, I spent much of the book waiting for the characters to catch up with information I already possessed.
Even when they finally do uncover the truth, it often feels more like a fortunate coincidence than the result of careful investigation. I wanted to see them put the clues together, question their assumptions, and arrive at conclusions through their own reasoning. More importantly, I wanted the opportunity to do the same as a reader. A mystery is much more satisfying when I can actively participate in solving it, rather than simply watch the answers reveal themselves.
The romance was another aspect that didn't particularly excite me. From the moment Katherine meets Silas, it is fairly obvious where their relationship is heading. Their initial antagonism gradually develops into attraction, following a very familiar romantic formula. There is nothing especially wrong with it, but I didn't find it particularly original or compelling.
The book also contains several explicit scenes, which place it more comfortably in the adult or new adult category than traditional young adult fantasy. These scenes are certainly more than fade to black, although they are not excessively detailed. I thought they were perfectly fine, but the romance was never the main reason I was interested in the story. I was much more invested in the magical society, its internal politics, and the questions surrounding the exploitation of vulnerable witches.
Ultimately, Witch Season was an enjoyable read with an interesting premise and some genuinely worthwhile ideas. I particularly appreciated the finite nature of magic, the system of rune books, and the way the story connects magical privilege to inherited social advantages. The training programme for young witches was also a compelling element because it demonstrated that the established system's cruelty was not inevitable. There was a better alternative, but those in power simply refused to consider it.
My main frustration was that the plot never quite lived up to the potential of its worldbuilding. With several mysteries, political tensions, dangerous magical substances, and competing interests within the covens, there was plenty of material for a more intricate story. Instead, the various plotlines tended to resolve themselves before they could develop much complexity, leaving me wishing that the characters had been challenged a little more.
Nevertheless, I had a good time reading it, and I think it deserves its four stars. I would recommend it to readers who enjoy contemporary witchy fantasy with a structured magic system, political intrigue, social commentary, and a substantial romantic subplot. Just don't expect an especially challenging mystery.
For me, the most interesting question wasn't who was responsible for the various crimes, but why a society that depends so heavily on magic is so willing to abandon the very children who possess it.

Comments
Post a Comment